Goonhub
04-29-2025, 10:20 PM
This is just me and that others might disagree and not related to any feedback, but I think it's worth bearing in mind the following regarding getting feedback or not.
First, your application is pretty fresh still! If you look at other applications this cycle and approved/denied applications you'll see a pattern where it might take some time for feedback to come in.
One reason I suspect the application cycles are generally around two months is to give people time to read, consider and give feedback. It also has the benefit of putting you in the spotlight for maybe paying a bit more attention to how you're doing during the application period.
Further, it's worth bearing in mind that feedback is there not just for you to take on (which is a great part but not all of it) but also to help admins make their decision which is also entirely separate. There are plenty of approved applications with little feedback, and plenty of denied applications that are crammed with positive feedback. I have no idea of the specifics of how they arrive at a decision, but it's clear the quantity of feedback is not the deciding factor.
So for now, and again this is separate of any endorsement or critique I'd say don't be disheartened, get out there and enjoy the game playing some security and getting to engage with people, and hopefully that will encourage people who have a positive experience with you to come back here and give you some feedback.
First, your application is pretty fresh still! If you look at other applications this cycle and approved/denied applications you'll see a pattern where it might take some time for feedback to come in.
One reason I suspect the application cycles are generally around two months is to give people time to read, consider and give feedback. It also has the benefit of putting you in the spotlight for maybe paying a bit more attention to how you're doing during the application period.
Further, it's worth bearing in mind that feedback is there not just for you to take on (which is a great part but not all of it) but also to help admins make their decision which is also entirely separate. There are plenty of approved applications with little feedback, and plenty of denied applications that are crammed with positive feedback. I have no idea of the specifics of how they arrive at a decision, but it's clear the quantity of feedback is not the deciding factor.
So for now, and again this is separate of any endorsement or critique I'd say don't be disheartened, get out there and enjoy the game playing some security and getting to engage with people, and hopefully that will encourage people who have a positive experience with you to come back here and give you some feedback.