Let's make the station more maintenance intensive!

[Walrus]

This is a cool idea. Nothing ever goes wrong without someone being behind it. Now you can frame Joe Q. Pubbie for breaking your APC because you saw him hanging around maint earlier!

If the engine goes down, it's a luxury for someone to even attempt to repair it.

That's because the station can operate independently from the engine (which is completely stupid in it's own way), why would anyone need to fix it if there is no benefit? If the power goes out in genetics/science/sec etc., they will fix it.

No one will fix any of this. People are breaking windows left and right. No one cares about maintenance. This would be great on an RP server.

Windows never need to be fixed unless it's a hull breach and there's a vacuum pulling air out, and in that case people will fix it. You can't claim to speak for everyone else just because you don't like the idea.