What is creepy?

[Spy_Guy]

That seems good, but on the other hand it kind of makes it seem like the genitals bit is negotiable which is a very clear line. Extreme torture feels more at home in the "This includes..." sentence because of this. While none of the things in that sentence are acceptable, this is covered by the genitals clause.

If that didn't make sense it's because I'm way tired

Yeah no I stuck it there because I worried that if it was before the genitals bit, they might parse it as 'hm so extreme torture that DOESN'T involve the genitals is A-OK then!' How about:

This includes rape jokes, roleplaying sex, sexual harassment/assault, or rape. If it involves your genitals, or extreme torture, it doesn't belong here. Stuff relating to your bathing suit area is absolutely not allowed under any circumstances, but if you're not sure if something else you're plotting crosses the line, it's probably best not to do it until you've discussed it on the forums or IRC. Adminhelp is probably not the appropriate venue for this discussion.

Are you sure it'd be parsed like that, given that it's lumped together with things like roleplaying sex, sexual harassment/assault and rape? As it stands, having double clarifications for genitals being unacceptable seems slightly redundant to me and makes the entire thing a lot less concise.