Goonhub
03-18-2025, 10:27 PM
I have seen other rounds, and while I feel it's not quite there yet for feedback I do want to make a suggestion: Your general conversations on discord to me raise some flags about your mentality for a HoS role which I'll explain.
Just a brief search through of your recent history for examples:
In the questions segment (it is a question!)
and the exchange while discussing things with several HoS players in the same channel:
First, admire the confidence! and from what limited viewing I've seen so far the practical skills of being a security -officer- are down. That's a useful part of the HoS toolkit: it does help if they can teach be an example to other officers when they're needed in my opinion. But it's only part of their toolkit.
However, to me what seems to me like losing your temper on the questions section of discord and to me what seems like a developing pattern of "Every time I "Win" I am good but every time a thing stops me It is Bad" at least in how you're communicating is painting a picture that might impact your application, or at least is for me. Please bear in mind this is just my personal post and others may disagree with this assessment.
I'd suggest thinking a bit about how you're communicating with players there. It's definitely okay to be confident, and it's okay to be frustrated, but demonstrating you've got a good way to cope with both (such as "huh, I think this feature might need tweaking, let me make a forum post about how I'd fix it and see if others agree" and hopefully some give-and-take when talking with people post round) and if you're curbstomping antagonists: hopefully knowing when to give some space for them for round pacing (which you may be, hence why this isn't a review yet, just some feedback) and how the players involved might be feeling seeing comments like:
I stress that this isn't a -1 for me currently. I have been watching a few rounds and haven't seen the behaviour Joeled highlighted, though I would keep in mind that behaving negatively in a round, (and failing completely to communicate effectively in a round is pretty negative for a HoS) is going to hurt an application for every 9 rounds you have that are good. Just something I'd personally keep in mind as the application period continues. You're welcome to dismiss it.
Just a brief search through of your recent history for examples:
Quote:"how the fuck is the butcher's knife remotely fair? a 5 second knockdown for just hitting a throw is absolutely insane, and then you can't even be cloned afterwards? who thought this was a good idea?"
In the questions segment (it is a question!)
and the exchange while discussing things with several HoS players in the same channel:
Quote:you misunderstand
i said I just do win. not that I strive to win
simply too skilled
ive gotten sec practically mastered like the back of my hand is what i want to say
First, admire the confidence! and from what limited viewing I've seen so far the practical skills of being a security -officer- are down. That's a useful part of the HoS toolkit: it does help if they can teach be an example to other officers when they're needed in my opinion. But it's only part of their toolkit.
However, to me what seems to me like losing your temper on the questions section of discord and to me what seems like a developing pattern of "Every time I "Win" I am good but every time a thing stops me It is Bad" at least in how you're communicating is painting a picture that might impact your application, or at least is for me. Please bear in mind this is just my personal post and others may disagree with this assessment.
I'd suggest thinking a bit about how you're communicating with players there. It's definitely okay to be confident, and it's okay to be frustrated, but demonstrating you've got a good way to cope with both (such as "huh, I think this feature might need tweaking, let me make a forum post about how I'd fix it and see if others agree" and hopefully some give-and-take when talking with people post round) and if you're curbstomping antagonists: hopefully knowing when to give some space for them for round pacing (which you may be, hence why this isn't a review yet, just some feedback) and how the players involved might be feeling seeing comments like:
Quote:"hey you guys got any reccomendations for HoS 'prerequisites'? I've got security down and now it's just kind of boring to play it since I always kinda... win over antags.
I stress that this isn't a -1 for me currently. I have been watching a few rounds and haven't seen the behaviour Joeled highlighted, though I would keep in mind that behaving negatively in a round, (and failing completely to communicate effectively in a round is pretty negative for a HoS) is going to hurt an application for every 9 rounds you have that are good. Just something I'd personally keep in mind as the application period continues. You're welcome to dismiss it.