Pillows

[Kotlol]

Maybe wool from dolly, or any other cloth/ knitting, combined with feathers dropped from chickens (provided they make chickens drop feathers) like babayetu suggested? It'd give the rancher a good side gig while they wait for chickens to do their thing

Yeah, that'd be good as well. I think feathers only drop when you kill chickens, though, but I don't play rancher enough to say so with certainty.

Sometimes they can drop feathers by petting or grabbing em I believe. Killing them assures it.